Thursday, March 17, 2011

My (short) journey w/ a Z13

Been lurking here a while reading the various forums for Sony, Lenovo, Dell (business) and HP (business) and finally bit the bullet and ordered a Z133 from the Microsoft Store.



Unfortunately, the machine didn't live up to my expectations or Sony's claim of 7 hours of battery life and I wanted to share a few points for folks like me who may be sitting on the fence deciding between a sandy bridge model and the current Z.



First, here's what I was looking for in a machine:
  • Weight somewhere between 3 - 3.5lbs
  • 12-13” screen w/ good colors, contrast, viewing angle
  • Core i5 or better
  • SSD (100gb+, don't need a huge one)
  • 6-7 hour battery life for Windows (MacBooks don’t hit this)
  • HDMI or digital output on the notebook itself (not via docking)
  • Good keyboard and multitouch trackpad


The Z hits all of these on paper, but I found it lacking for a few reasons:
  • Real-life battery life is nowhere near claimed @ 7hrs. 4 hours was typical.
  • While it's a multitouch trackpad you have to find drivers and apps to get two-finger scrolling. It's finicky at best, mis-clicks were common. I'm used to Apple's trackpads under Windows. I imagine Lenovo's are better as well.
  • Loose battery rattled while moving/carrying it. Not cool for a $1700 machine.
  • No recovery DVDs? I don't like recovery partitions, let me use the 6 gigs!
  • The screen, while great, was a bit too-high resolution for me. I'm not that old but 1600x900 was a bit too much. Most people will be fine with this, I wasn't. Running at a higher DPI setting was ugly. Lower res = blurry.
  • The machine just felt 'cheap'. I'm used to MacBook and Lenovo chassis and the Sony doesn't live up here. Not saying that it isn't durable or wouldn't stand the test of time, but if I'm going to be typing on it every day I want something that is top notch.


Anyway, on to waiting for the sandy bridge models, looking at these machines:
  • Lenovo x220 w/ IPS
  • Sony Vaio SB Series (will the screen be any good?)
  • Samsung 9 Series


Anyway, great forum and resources here no matter which brand someone ends up with. Comment/flame away



Edit: The machine went back to the Microsoft Store after a couple days. GREAT service from them.

Reply 1 : My (short) journey w/ a Z13

Sorry to hear that you had a bad time with the Z13, I get 5.5 to 7 hours out of my new Z13. Were you using the stamina mode options? If you run it at full pelt I agree the battery life can be poor.

Reply 2 : My (short) journey w/ a Z13

A few comments based on my knowledge and small experience with the Z:




Quote:








Originally Posted by terret
View Post

The Z hits all of these on paper, but I found it lacking for a few reasons:
  • Real-life battery life is nowhere near claimed @ 7hrs. 4 hours was typical. -
  • While it's a multitouch trackpad you have to find drivers and apps to get two-finger scrolling. It's finicky at best, mis-clicks were common. I'm used to Apple's trackpads under Windows. I imagine Lenovo's are better as well. -
  • Loose battery rattled while moving/carrying it. Not cool for a $1700 machine.
  • No recovery DVDs? I don't like recovery partitions, let me use the 6 gigs! -
  • The screen, while great, was a bit too-high resolution for me. I'm not that old but 1600x900 was a bit too much. Most people will be fine with this, I wasn't. Running at a higher DPI setting was ugly. Lower res = blurry.
  • The machine just felt 'cheap'. I'm used to MacBook and Lenovo chassis and the Sony doesn't live up here. Not saying that it isn't durable or wouldn't stand the test of time, but if I'm going to be typing on it every day I want something that is top notch.



Reply 3 : My (short) journey w/ a Z13


Quote:








Originally Posted by terret
View Post

The Z hits all of these on paper, but I found it lacking for a few reasons:
  • Real-life battery life is nowhere near claimed @ 7hrs. 4 hours was typical.

    It's like that with all laptops, you never get near advertised times. If u go low brightness, wifi off and all in powersave you should get around 6 hours (with wifi more like 4,5 - 5)
  • While it's a multitouch trackpad you have to find drivers and apps to get two-finger scrolling. It's finicky at best, mis-clicks were common. I'm used to Apple's trackpads under Windows. I imagine Lenovo's are better as well.

    Wow i hope you didn't fall asleep from such a long day. It's fixable in like 2min with new synaptic drivers
  • Loose battery rattled while moving/carrying it. Not cool for a $1700 machine.

    It's by design, apparantly for expanding/shrinking of battery during temperature changes. Maybe a bit lame reasoning, but it seems that's why the did it.
  • No recovery DVDs? I don't like recovery partitions, let me use the 6 gigs!

    About 95% of the laptops from the last few(3?) years have had a recovery partition and a question at first boot to burn the disk. It's as normal as it can get nowadays. And with a simple partitioning program it's gone in 2mins.
  • The screen, while great, was a bit too-high resolution for me. I'm not that old but 1600x900 was a bit too much. Most people will be fine with this, I wasn't. Running at a higher DPI setting was ugly. Lower res = blurry.

    personal preference, nothing to do with the laptop
  • The machine just felt 'cheap'. I'm used to MacBook and Lenovo chassis and the Sony doesn't live up here. Not saying that it isn't durable or wouldn't stand the test of time, but if I'm going to be typing on it every day I want something that is top notch.

    yeah it's not completely aluminium, but it's sturdy enough. Just because it feels like it doesn't mean it actually is ''cheap''. And 2nd i guess you never felt a cheap notebook before? Since the Z feels way better.



see the above for comments on the Z.



Other than that, it seems the SA/SB series will look even cheaper, but that might be just me.

Reply 4 : My (short) journey w/ a Z13


Quote:








Originally Posted by hxkclan
View Post

Other than that, it seems the SA/SB series will look even cheaper, but that might be just me.



If you mean design-wise - I'm 100% with you. Compared to Z and S - hideous!!



Other than that - should be at least as robust as the S, which IMO is very durable, especially the base (not to be compared with Lenovo T though - those are rather industrial machines).

Reply 5 : My (short) journey w/ a Z13

I ad ordered the Z13 to replace my Toshiba M400 and as mentioned in another thread it came defective, so I had to send it back... my journey was all of maybe 15 minutes. But I would find 4 hours outstanding compared to my Toshiba which was lucky to make it about 90 minutes on battery (and that was when the battery was relatively new... today it's more like about 60). So I'm pretty much tethered to a wall socket, and I'm trying to get away from that at least to some degree.



In the end I found I actually do want the FHD screen... in the brief time I had it and even used it with RDP I found the resolution to be OK for me. So yeah, I understand it is a matter of personal preference... if I had decided the resolution was just too fine I would have gone to a 15" model of some kind instead.

Reply 6 : My (short) journey w/ a Z13


Quote:








Originally Posted by terret
View Post

[*]Real-life battery life is nowhere near claimed @ 7hrs. 4 hours was typical.



Totally agree. 4 hours is about right on stamina.




Quote:








Originally Posted by terret
View Post

[*]While it's a multitouch trackpad you have to find drivers and apps to get two-finger scrolling. It's finicky at best, mis-clicks were common. I'm used to Apple's trackpads under Windows. I imagine Lenovo's are better as well.



Totally agree. Two finger scrolling is a mess. The TP is twitcy. I've turned off all the click modes and only use it as a mouse mover.




Quote:








Originally Posted by terret
View Post

[*]Loose battery rattled while moving/carrying it. Not cool for a $1700 machine.



My battery is tight. $1700 from the Microsoft Store?!?!?!?!?!?. Man, they saw you coming didn't they. The max price anyone should pay for the Z from Microsoft Store should be about $1100 and change. That's before the various GC kickbacks, the student discount and cashback.




Quote:








Originally Posted by terret
View Post

[*]No recovery DVDs? I don't like recovery partitions, let me use the 6 gigs!



Dude, welcome to the 21st century. Who ships DVDs anymore? Make your own then recover the lost space.




Quote:








Originally Posted by terret
View Post

[*]The screen, while great, was a bit too-high resolution for me. I'm not that old but 1600x900 was a bit too much. Most people will be fine with this, I wasn't. Running at a higher DPI setting was ugly. Lower res = blurry.



I agree. I disagree about cranking the DPI. Yes, some apps do look bad, but you can selective crank the DPI.




Quote:








Originally Posted by terret
View Post

[*]The machine just felt 'cheap'. I'm used to MacBook and Lenovo chassis and the Sony doesn't live up here. Not saying that it isn't durable or wouldn't stand the test of time, but if I'm going to be typing on it every day I want something that is top notch.



Dude, when I first played with the Z in store. I wasn't feeling the love. I said it felt like a $600 computer and not a $2000 one. Now... It's grown on me. It's a little jewel. The keyboard is still rubbish though. Might as well be typing on a MacBook. Sony should contract out the keyboard from Lenovo.



Bottom line is. What else can you find with it's spec in a 13" 3lb or smaller package? You can't. The Z is the only game in town. Paying $1700 was too much. If you paid about $1000 would you have kept it?

Reply 7 : My (short) journey w/ a Z13

Anyway, on to waiting for the sandy bridge models, looking at these machines:
  • Lenovo x221 w/ IPS
  • Sony Vaio SB Series (will the screen be any good?)
  • Samsung 9 Series






Samsung 9 series will cost an arm and a leg..



Lenovo X221 is not out nor planned yet. Just the X220 with IPS screen will be released in early April (Reviews are out and outstanding)



Vaio SB is nice, but not as good I believe than the SA series that has yet to be released

Reply 8 : My (short) journey w/ a Z13


Quote:








Originally Posted by SR45
View Post

Samsung 9 series will cost an arm and a leg..



Lenovo X221 is not out nor planned yet. Just the X220 with IPS screen will be released in early April (Reviews are out and outstanding)



Vaio SB is nice, but not as good I believe than the SA series that has yet to be released



SA has the higher resolution screen which obviously is not a good idea. So SB would be the way to go... or current S if he doesn't insist on Sandy.



Besides that "not as good as" means nothing unless you specify in what fashion you mean it. If the build quality is the same, there is no such thing as "as good as". There is only better configuration for more money.

Reply 9 : My (short) journey w/ a Z13

As Gracy said, if you think the 1600X900 screen is too high res for you, the SB should be right up your alley with a 1366X768 screen. With the extra "sheet" batter the manufacturer claims up to 15 hours total charge (so expect 10-12 in real life?)

No comments:

Post a Comment